Peter Frankopan
  • Home
  • About Peter
  • The Earth Transformed
  • The Silk Roads
  • The New Silk Roads
  • Silk Roads - Illustrated
    • The First Crusade
  • I've Been Thinking.....
  • Academic work
  • Press & Media
  • Public Events
  • Contact
Welcome

Peter's blog

I blog from time to time about things that catch my eye and particularly about links between the past and present.

Peter's Blog

On History, Homer and Ben Affleck

2/26/2013

1 Comment

 
Picture
Affleck in Argo: great hair
So, Argo wins Best Picture at the Oscars. The story of the Iran hostage crisis in 1979 made for a gripping tale, packed with tension and adrenaline. It was not easy, tweeted Ben Affleck, in response to gushing praise, 'to play a role in a true story - you have a responsibility to tell the truth, as well as make a good movie' (@benaffleck).

The film - and its director's comments - made some choke into their morning cereal, such as the many hundreds of people who responded to Guy Walters' reasoned and withering critique of the flaws, errors and distortions of Argo that you can read here. Many were appalled at how Britain's role in the crisis was cruelly twisted in the movie in the name of 'dramatic license.' Others, including leading critics in the US, also pulled few punches about the film's accuracy. 'Argo: Too Good to be True, Because It Isn't' - was the headline of David Edelstein's review on NPR.

For shame, chant the critics, Argo plays too fast with the past.

One of the great regrets about being a historian is the lack of a glittering annual awards ceremony, where leading practitioners get to dress up in evening gowns, be fawned over by an adoring public and string together a few short but inane sentences to thank the neighbours’ cat before bursting into tears.

But we should, I think, cut Hollywood some slack. It is easy to forget that history is all about dramatic license. Who wants to read a boring account of the past? Which historian does not want to spice things up? And even as far as flaws, errors and distortions go – well, bring them on. Historians revel in them as cinema-goers revel in their tubs of popcorn: our job is to find the problems and mistakes in Herodotus, to tear up the textbooks about the Crusades by showing why received opinions are wrong, to challenge accepted views about the decline of the British empire – and to re-assess the past by working out who got things wrong.

As a historian, while twisting things on purpose can hardly get two thumbs up, I can't begrudge Argo. After all, the principle of shaping a story to move it along is one the film shares with many of the great histories of the past that do exactly the same thing. Try telling Arrian that it was not one tribe but another who got in Alexander the Great's way as he crossed central Asia or that he missed a bit out; or Gibbon that his assessment of the Byzantine empire as degenerate was not just unfair but flat wrong; or modern commentators in United States that their views about the Middle East, the Arab spring and contemporary Russia are poorly informed and riddled with misunderstandings. It happens.

While I never thought I'd say it (especially after the 'Bennifer' debacle – and double especially after being forced by my children to watch the giant turkey that is Pearl Harbour recently), I’m with Ben Affleck on this one. The story he tells in Argo may not be spot on. But then again, history has a funny tendency not to be: facts get in the way of a good story surprisingly often.

Much more interesting than Affleck-bashing is why there is a swell of feel-good for a triumph over adversity story involving US policy in Iran right now, and why Argo had a resonance that played so well with the Academy. Something to do, perhaps, with supporting the American intelligence agencies in part of the world where we all fear the future, and with the insecurities about the pressures on the west in a changing world: Argo is, after all, nothing if not a classic ‘get in the lifeboat story’, a tale of salvation from the jaws of disaster.

In that sense, Argo should not be judged on whether it is historically reliable; it should be understood as a morality tale which tells us who the good guys are (USA/CIA) and who the bad guys are (Iran, who else), and does not need to bother about anyone else (e.g. the Brits).

So a bit like The Odyssey, then, albeit perhaps not quite as profound (despite the Best Movie) – and I’m not sure Odysseus would be flattered with the comparison to Ben Affleck (despite his luxuriant hair). Both, after all, were entertainment – rather than great works of history.

Now, about my Tom Ford tuxedo for the historians’ award ceremony. And the nominees are….
1 Comment
Keiron Allen
3/2/2013 08:43:00 pm

I agree Pete. One of my favourite quotes about history and film was Woodrow Wilson on D. W. Griffith's film "Birth of a Nation" - "It was like writing History with lightning". There's so much to say about this film, few people realised it was the highest grossing film until Gone with the wind.. There are two rather lovely slides that are sometimes included in the opening credits that are relevant here I feel: "A PLEA FOR THE ART OF THE MOTION PICTURE: We do not fear censorship, for we have no wish to offend with improprieties or obscenities, but we do demand, as a right, the liberty to show the dark side of wrong, that we may illuminate the bright side of virtue – the same liberty that is conceded to the art of the written word – that art to which we owe the Bible and the works of Shakespeare"
and
"If in this work we have conveyed to the mind the ravages of war to the end that war may be held in abhorrence, this effort will not have been in vain." Perhaps that was his intention over his depiction of the KKK etc...

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    I'm trying out micro-blogging -short bits of things I think are interesting every now and again. I'm on twitter too if you prefer doses of 140 characters

    Archives

    October 2018
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013

    Categories

    All
    Byzantine
    Byzantine Empire
    Byzantine Empire
    Cats
    China
    Constantinople
    Crusades
    David Bowie
    Dolce & Gabbana
    Downton Abbey
    Emperor
    Fashion
    First Crusade
    Football
    Istanbul
    Medieval
    Middle Ages
    Mongols
    Nomads
    Pilgrimage
    Putin
    Stylite
    Titles
    V&A
    X Factor
    Zoolander

    RSS Feed