Peter Frankopan
  • Home
  • About Peter
  • The Earth Transformed
  • The Silk Roads
  • The New Silk Roads
  • Silk Roads - Illustrated
    • The First Crusade
  • I've Been Thinking.....
  • Academic work
  • Press & Media
  • Public Events
  • Contact
Welcome

Peter's blog

I blog from time to time about things that catch my eye and particularly about links between the past and present.

Peter's Blog

Downton Abbey, the literature of medieval Byzantium and the Homeric epic

9/23/2013

0 Comments

 
And so last night, after what felt like months (precisely 12 in fact), Downton returned to the screen. The twitter-sphere lit up with gasps, comments about who looked good in bowler hats and much friendly 'advice' for the show's writers about current and potential future plot lines.

Downton thrives because it achieves a near-perfect blend of fact and fiction - with real events setting a context for the ups, downs and sideways for the Earls of Grantham. The very first episode of the very first series set the tone, with news solemnly reported of the sinking of the Titanic.

While Downton has been a phenomenon, a smash hit on both sides of the Atlantic, it bears many similarities with medieval and ancient Greek literature: blockbuster epics where the blend of reality and a bit of artistic license made story-lines as explosive, dramatic and gripping as the Sunday night prime-time slot is today.
Picture
Aristocratic Blockbuster setting
Picture
Imperial Blockbuster setting
That is not surprising, as all were intended as Entertainment (with a capital E). In the Byzantine Empire there were even the equivalent of the commissioning editor, the svengali looking for a smash-hit that would liven up dinner and the weekends, and get people gossiping at the water cooler (OK, at the baths).

The Alexiad was written in the 12th Century, for example, after the Empress Eirene asked for a good, racy account of the below and above stairs plots in the palace that would have given Downton a run for its money. Ooh - the servants Borilos and Germanos were planning a take-over from behind the scenes in 1080; who'd have believed it ! She even turned to a new writer to keep it going after the first person she commissioned keeled over and died after working too hard (that, and falling ill while on military campaign).
PictureLeading family (pictured with staff)
It's easy to think that people were any more forgiving about the blurred lines between fact and fiction then than they are today: Downton is sheer fantasy, says one commentator, sucking lemons. Look at all the historical errors, roar others, their lists eagerly picked up by newspapers with column inches to fill.

Picture
Leading family with close friends (staff out of shot)
But ancient and medieval literature was no different. There were endless slinging matches between authors with rival accounts of what had 'really' happened. This naturally makes unpicking the narrative accounts and telling reality from make-believe really quite hard.
And it's made worse by the fact that it's so hard to pick out all the in-jokes and little references - the cheeky asides to Plutarch and Horace that would have brought chuckles, nods and winks to readers of the Alexiad, and to those who had sections of the text read out as after-dinner Entertainment. Just like references to rogue financiers, credit crunches and wars gone wrong abroad to in Downton, the trick was to make it all seem surprisingly modern and relevant - but about 'the good old days' at the same time.
Eyebrows would have raised at the depiction of some characters as being too good to be true and of others taken down a couple of notches. The people who supported the conspiracy of a certain Nikephoros Diogenes in the 1090s were fools, an 'utterly gormless' lot, convinced they were watching a genius when they saw their man chuck a spear a few feet through the air (Prime Time Saturday night audience watching Ant & Dec, perhaps). The hero of the Alexiad, by contrast, was scrupulously fair, always weighing the evidence carefully when given a choice, and really taking his time before making a considered decision (no idea how long it took him to choose from a menu, but you get the sense he was not the ideal person to grab a quick bite to eat with).

The point of the literature was to amuse and instruct, to give an insight into the past; it was certainly not to give a fact based account of history, reported in tones reminiscent of 19th century newspapers that would send you to sleep and question whether improving national literary levels were really worth the trouble. On the contrary - the more skullduggery, evil villains and heroic acts of selflessness the better.
Picture
Lord Grantham
Picture
The perfidious Scyth manservant, Borilos
Take Digenis Akrites, for example, one of the great poems of the medieval world (tragically understudied) and its tales of doomed love, of triumph over adversity, of daring and cliff-hangers that would make Julian Fellowes green with envy. Now THAT's Entertainment. Killing bears with your hands - take that Matthew Crawley (sniff); what's that - a dragon? Boom - gone! Think you can do better, Carson?

Or Homer, with the twisting plot lines, carefully-weaved story that was too neat and predictable for some. Well, of COURSE, Odysseus was going to make it home; what did you expect ??! Would his beloved old dog recognise him after only 20 years away; this is showbusiness, guys, so you do the maths. That Cyclops - did you really think he'd snaffle the hero ? Was that nice Branson going to - oh wait, that's Downton again.

The point is that Entertainment is, well, Entertainment. After my bit to push X-Factor viewing figures clearly worked last week, I'm hoping to have the same effect on Downton Abbey. Julian Fellowes, Anna Komnene and Homer; Lady Mary, Alexios Komnenos and Odysseus. 3,000 years of prime time all linked neatly together. You read it here first, people.
0 Comments

The First Crusade, the X Factor and the Y Generation

9/11/2013

0 Comments

 
As far as our household is concerned, there are three New Years. One on 1st January (fair enough); another when school goes back in September (yes, OK); and another when the new season of X Factor starts at the end of August.

Thousands upon thousands of hopefuls queue up, drawn by the dreams of making in big and by the drive deep within the heart that makes almost every single one of them assert (usually through tears) that 'I really, really want this more than anything, I really really want it.'
PictureQueuing for Clermont 1095
I don't know how many other medieval historians watch X Factor - though a straw poll amongst my peers in Oxford suggests more than you might think (just because you obsess about William of Malmesbury's sources or about new coin finds by the Danube does not mean you're not human, you know!). It should be compulsory watching for anyone interested in the Crusades.

PictureQueuing for X Factor Auditions

In 1095, Pope Urban gave an electrifying speech at Clermont in Central France, calling for armed men to join an expedition to save the Byzantine Empire which was teetering on the point of collapse (I have written a book about this). As word spread around Europe that something was going to be done to save Constantinople, the most important city in Europe with treasuries filled with Christianity's crown jewels, and better still, then carry on to Jerusalem, young men - and women - clamoured to take part.

Their motivations for doing so were varied, many of them conflicting: it was well-known that the journey east was long, dangerous and expensive. So leaving family behind was a wrench; and it cost a lot; and there was a good chance of not making it back alive.

But think of the rewards in the next life - that was the priests' favourite line. Sure. But also think of the glory, said the vaguer, medieval public school types; think of the financial rewards, thought the sharper ones on the make; think of what fun it will be, friends will have cajoled each other; think of what people will say if you don't go (a few of the sterner fathers would have tried that); and remember, darling, with thousands taking part, it will never be safer (the common sense of the mother, I suspect).

Unscrambling those is not easy, despite the solemn and dry explanations set out most historians of this period, who talk religious conviction, faith and endless variations of similar noble causes. Where's the fun, guys - and where's real life?

What about the peer pressure; where's the one drink too many, of course I'm coming promise that turns into something serious. Where's the showing off to the foxy daughter of the local landowner who's bound to be impressed? Where's the reluctant knight who had other things he was planning to do; or the one whose eyesight just wasn't that great and who didn't fancy it?
Well, look no further than X Factor for the perfect modern counter-sample. What anyone who watches can tell you, no two people are the same. While it's normally easy to tell a good 'un from a bad 'un, sometimes you get a surprise. But what's most striking is how many people come, year after year, to take part and to audition.
Picture
X Factor Crusade style
Picture
Logo coincidence - I don't think so
They are drawn, just like the Crusaders, by the conviction that the upside outweighs the downside: the shot at glory, riches, fame, eternal life made the risk of embarrassment, humiliation and (social) death worth it. Some are egged on by friends whose blind faith in their talent is touching - especially when it is profoundly misplaced; others are driven by desperation, by their fears and their hope of a better life.

For those who go on to the live shows - woohoo ! - and reach the final stages attain a level of fame claimed by those who returned from the Holy Land after the capture of Jerusalem in 1099. The Crusaders were feted and mobbed as One Direction are today; there were signings, portraits, songs - you name it - when they got home.
Picture
Judges Houses : 21st century
Picture
Judges Houses: c.12th century
The Gary Barlow of the age was Bohemond: men wanted to hang out with him; women wanted to marry him. (I can tell you now, by the way, that our Gary is nothing like that 'Norman dog' as one Byzantine source called him).
Picture
Bohemond: scoundrel
Picture
Gary: lovely guy
Just like X Factor has its share of idiots, so did the Crusade. In the case of the TV show, the worst that happens is that security gets called and a can or two gets kicked by the wannabe hero who comes off the hinges; in the Crusade, there was no such safety net: thousands of Jews were murdered as the lunatic fringe went on the rampage, shouting ever louder how much they want it more than anything. The Y generation in the 11th century gave as little reason to proud as their peers ten centuries later.
Picture
Nope
Picture
That's three nos
Picture
And it's a No from me
This week David Attenborough has spoken of his belief that humans have stopped evolving. I can't tell you much about that. But what I can say is that human beings have not changed so much as some of my medieval historian colleagues think. Just because it was the Middle Ages, not all men were noble, not everyone was convinced by devotion, not all were pious, and not everyone was guided and led by their faith.

That, of course, is what the Simon Cowells of the day wanted you to believe. The medieval monks who wrote the histories of the Crusade and of this period were PR men par excellence. No superyachts, fast cars and messy relationships for them (erm...); but just like with the evil genius behind X Factor, the cash flowed in. All those cathedrals where you went if you wanted to hear real singing weren't free, you know.

Picture
Coining it in
Picture
If you could make it out for 'Cash' please
0 Comments

The standing man & stylites of Istanbul (and Constantinople)

6/27/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture'Istanbul was Constantinople'
The Four Lads may not feature on many bibliographies on the history of the great imperial city of Constantinople. But they were spot on.

'Istanbul was Constantinople', they sang, entirely accurately. 'Now it's Istanbul, not Constantinople'; correct again.

'Why did Constantinople get the works?' they mused; 'That's nobody's business but the Turks'

It's a classic - an all time great, and required listening (you can click on the link above and listen as you read if you like).

Despite the wisdom of the Four Lads, though, some things never change. The inhabitants of the great city nestled on the banks of the Bosphorus have been up in arms, protesting against the heavy-handed and bloody-mindedness of the Prime Minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. It is the latest in a long and proud line of civic disobedience that stretches back to the early 4th century when the city was magnificently endowed by the Emperor Constantine.

PictureRoom with a view
As Byzantine Emperors and Turkish sultans learned from experience, when crowds take to the streets of the city, it was time to listen. Erdoğan is not interested; it's all the fault of 'provocateurs' and 'social media', he claims. He should study his history.

If he had, he'd quickly learn about the Stylites of Constantinople, men who would climb to the top of a column to be closer to God, and to demonstrate their devotion through their asceticism. Some, like Daniel in the 5th century, took up position by the harbour, so those journeying in and out of the city could see him literally standing up for what he believed in. People would shout up questions to him - and he'd answer, impressing all with his simple advice.

Picture'The Standing Man'
For all those who say history does not repeat itself, how wonderful to see that after being swamped with tear gas, the protesters in Istanbul have reverted to old tradition of making a stand.

The symbol of the recent protests is none other than a modern day stylite - dubbed the standing man.

PictureNew Day, New Outfit. Same pose
He stands still, silently (occasionally disappearing to change his outfit); his aim is to make a pacific and ascetic protest against the powers that be. He will hold his ground, and do so proudly, quietly and without a fuss. The stylites of old would be proud of him - and delighted to see their traditions being re-adopted, even if the spiritual side is rather watered down.

Even better, clusters of new standing figures have now joined him. This happened too with popular stylites in the old days, with others setting up columns near by (I might be wrong, but suspect this was really annoying for the first holy man who got in to position; I bet there was a lot of the silent treatment for new arrivals until they proved themselves). And despite what they say, size did matter - what was worse than another stylite joining the party? A stylite with a bigger column, that's what.
Picture
Standing Men
A shame then that instead of perching on top of a column (needs planning permission; not very robust against a high-pressure water cannon etc), the protestors are showing solidarity by standing still and silent, united by matching T-Shirts.

If anyone wants to send me one, I'll put it on and find a suitably lofty location in the dreaming spires of Oxford - and show them how it's done old school.
Picture
A Gang of Stylites in the 'hood
0 Comments

Vladimir Putin: a classic Byzantine emperor

6/11/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
Vladimir Putin gets a bad press in the western world - there are sniggers that he is too autocratic; too controlling and too repressive. The judo and the motorbike-riding, the bare-chested fishing; shirtless horse riding; surfacing from scuba-diving with two intact Greek amphorae - I mean, come on, I hear you cry. It's a joke !

But one thing about Putin is that he certainly knows how to handle his image, and how to handle his personal life. Those images of his down-time activities are chosen carefully - more carefully than those of US Presidents enjoying seemingly never-ending rounds of golf while the economy tanks (as at 1 June 2013, Pres. Obama had played 125 rounds since taking office)

Despite Putin's immense power (and rumoured vast wealth), he consistently presents himself as a servant of his people - a trick learned from the Emperors of Byzantium.

His divorce, announced last week with his wife at his side after seeing a performance of La Esmeralda, was straight from the imperial textbooks.'All my work is connected to the public sphere', he told a reporter from RIA Novosti, a state-owned gazeteer. 'Some like it; but there are people who are completely incompatible with that.' I live to serve, in other words; deal with it.

The message was reinforced immediately by his court historians. 'It’s easy to look at Putin’s working schedule' said his official spokesman, 'and you’ll understand that his life is not connected in any way with family relationships. It’s connected only with his responsibility as the head of state.

They must have been reading the Alexiad, a jewel of a medieval text written in Greek in the 12th century
.
The Emperor Alexios I, wrote the author, never had time to bathe since he was so busy with affairs of state. He hardly slept, and worried constantly about the waves battering the empire from all quarters. His wife used to spend the evenings reading the Bible - just like Ludmilla Putin is supposed to do; on those rare occasions they were together, they would talk and pray - Emperor and Empress, that is; would not be surprised to learn that about the Putins too in due course.

Empresses were often quietly discarded in Byzantium, usually retiring to well-appointed convents where they lived out their days in luxurious surroundings. Almost always, they went off into the distance - like Mrs P - smiling and calm, aware that they had made their bed with a powerful man and for whatever reason, that end of the road had been reached.

But I for one found the process of last week's announcement surprisingly familiar, but also impressive in its own way. Ludmilla accepting her fate in a way that showed considerable dignity; and Putin himself keeping up the image that is a constant - and a reason why he is so enormously popular in Russia. He is steering the ship and is constantly at the helm, as waves crash from all directions.

No time for middle class sports like golf for him or a moccacino in a dinky little cafe in Ibiza like the Camerons; if he's off duty, he's going to be out and about doing the sort of thing real leaders do - hunting, traveling and preserving Russia's cultural heritage.

No wonder Moscow has long styled itself as the Third Rome - their latest heir to Constantinople. Which makes me wonder: what is the model for London and for Washington?
0 Comments

On Derek Zoolander, Fashion & the Byzantine Empire

3/7/2013

3 Comments

 
Picture
Dolce & Gabbana AW 2013 Collection
The Byzantine Empire, as Derek Zoolander might say, is so hot right now.

This has been a good week to be a specialist on the Byzantine Empire. Usually, the name alone is enough to inspire a blank look, prompting a scratch of the head and a raid of the memory banks to remember when it flourished, where it was and what it was; it's the look perfected in fact by winner of Best Male Model award, Hansel.

I never expected that I would have one of the world's leading fashion houses to thank for putting a spring in my step until I saw pictures of Dolce & Gabbana's fall & winter collection for 2013, unveiled at Milan Fashion week a few days ago.

Dominated by Byzantine art, mosaics and images of powerful women 'inspired' by the wonderful cathedral of Santa Maria Nuova at Monreale, the collection went down well with the fashionistas - and also, let me tell you, with the not very large Byzantine academic community across the world that has rolled in ecstasy (a few howls, mind, about the specific choices of image).

It is all wonderfully post-modern. The wealthy women who will wear these clothes (the men's collection has no Byzantine reference - boo!) will parade powerful images of their wealthy predecessors: rulers, donors and saints. Were rich women today really more liberated than in the past? Will choice by about which item(s) to buy be based solely on colour - will it matter if the image is one of someone who was brutally martyred? And was that any different to a worshipper who looked at the images a thousand years ago - did they know who was in the picture either?

What I like best of all though as the images were not taken from imperial Constantinople, but from Norman Sicily. With delicious irony, they were put up by the Dolce & Gabbana of their day. The new Norman rulers who conquered the island wanted a magnificent cathedral. And they wanted bling by the bucket-load. Those mosaics are the fall/winter collection circa 1180. Those are the latest costumes, the finest fabrics and the latest looks in the medieval Mediterranean.

There's even a late 12th century parallel from Zoolander where Derek goes down the mines: hard labour as a source of spiritual redemption.
Picture
'Dig, boy, dig'
Picture
'I've got the black lung, pop'

Or here is Derek with Meekus and his housemates flashing Magnum in Zoolander (below) and, on the right, their medieval equivalents at Monreale:

Picture
'I'm pretty sure there's a lot more to life than being really, really, ridiculously good looking. And I plan on finding out what that is'
Picture
'What say we settle this on the runway?'

Once upon a time, religion and faith used to be about having fun, slapping gold on the walls of cathedrals and celebrating the good times. The medieval rich were ferocious philanthropists, endowing churches and paying for monks to do the hard work of praying for their souls, a neat combination.  No surprise then that when that all turned around in the Reformation - and dour sullen solemnity took over - it killed fashion too: Vogue would have been pretty slim in 17th century Europe with one black gloomy costume after another. Not much celebration on the catwalks or back at the crib; and forget about celebrating at church (which, is what 'eucharist' means after all).

Anyway, I can't wait to see the collection in real life, and will post when I do. After all, it's not everyday you find that after centuries in the shadows, not only is Byzantium hot, but that it is hot (well, haute) couture. And better still, it's coming to a boutique near you soon.
3 Comments

    Author

    I'm trying out micro-blogging -short bits of things I think are interesting every now and again. I'm on twitter too if you prefer doses of 140 characters

    Archives

    October 2018
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013

    Categories

    All
    Byzantine
    Byzantine Empire
    Byzantine Empire
    Cats
    China
    Constantinople
    Crusades
    David Bowie
    Dolce & Gabbana
    Downton Abbey
    Emperor
    Fashion
    First Crusade
    Football
    Istanbul
    Medieval
    Middle Ages
    Mongols
    Nomads
    Pilgrimage
    Putin
    Stylite
    Titles
    V&A
    X Factor
    Zoolander

    RSS Feed